![]()
|
"Consolidating Our Gains:"Consolidating Our Gains: Investing in Our Future" Investing in Our Future" Delivered by Honourable Lester
Bryant Bird Friday, 22nd
March , 2002 Twenty-one Years of Unbroken Growth Madam Speaker Our nation is in the year of its 21st
anniversary of independence. We have enjoyed 21 years of relative
peace and prosperity. We have experienced 21 years of
unbroken growth of our economy. Not the devastating effects of
Hurricane Luis in 1995 caused our growth to halt, not the unrelenting damage of five more
hurricanes in five years between 1995 and 2000 caused our growth to stop; not the
disastrous consequences of September 11th caused our growth to cease. We have done well. And the record
proves it. Not only have we enjoyed unbroken
economic growth, we have transformed the living conditions of our country. Our infant mortality rate is equal to
that of the United States. So too is life expectancy for both men and women. Health care
and medicines are available to all. Every child has a place in school, and any student who
has the capacity to pursue university education is assisted to do so. More Antiguans and
Barbudans own their own homes than ever in the history of our people. We have mastered the information
technology that underpins the beginning of the 21st Century, and the students from our
Institute of Technology can compete with the best in the world. We have also built-up a unique
physical infrastructure. There is electricity and pure water in every village and every
person has access to a telephone. Our business community benefits from
instant and reliable telecommunications to global markets and from an Airport and Port
that gives them unrestricted access to the world for their goods and services. While there have been political
disagreements and dissension among us, the rights of every person have continued to be
respected and upheld. There are no political prisoners in our jails, and no voices are
muzzled. There is no restriction on religious worship, and no restraint on political
affiliation. We have encouraged workers representation and upheld the value of trade
unionism. Democracy thrives in our nation as
does peace and relative prosperity. Over the last 21years, other nations
have not done as well. Some like Yugoslavia have split asunder, others such as Rwanda have
witnessed the worst tribal violence seen in recent time, many others in Africa, Asia and
Latin America have been savaged by internal warfare. Still others have been crippled by
violent crime and murder. Some economies have collapsed and millions of people are forced
to survive on less than one dollar a day. Neither democracy nor economic growth survived,
and people suffered. We faced no such hardships. Our nation thrived while many others
withered. Positive Role of Government These 21 years of growth, of peace and
relative prosperity did not come about by accident. They were made possible by three
things: There is no doubt that the people
worked hard to reconstruct this country after the devastation of Hurricane Luis. It is
also indisputable that after each successive natural disaster that we faced between 1995
and 2000, the people of this country displayed a remarkable capacity to put adversity
behind them and to rebuild their lives and the means of their livelihood. Some members of the business community
have also shown a readiness to contribute to the economy and to the progress of the
country. Unfortunately, this observation is not true of all. If it were, our economy would
have been even stronger today and our fiscal difficulties would never have occurred. But, it would be wrong not to
acknowledge the role played by businessmen who are prepared to put their money where their
mouth is in terms of contributing to the economic growth and development of this nation. In this connection, I pay tribute to
two members of the private sector: the ABI Financial Group and the Stanford Financial
Group. They both have diversified their businesses to the benefit of our economy. The ABI
Financial Group now owns the Antigua and Barbuda Investment Bank, the Antigua Overseas
Bank, an Insurance Company and the Jolly Beach Hotel - banking, insurance and tourism. The
Stanford Financial Group, led by Allen Stanford, has also made a considerable investment
in our economy in banking, construction, aviation and tourism. In both cases, these two
Groups have strived to establish high standards in all that they do. Our country has
benefited from their efforts. Jack should be given his jacket, as we say in Antiguan
parlance. Both these companies are leaders in the field and they richly deserve their
"jackets". Of course, not all the private sector
has been as diligent in contributing to the economy. Indeed, for the most part, the
private sector has not pulled its weight. Worse still, many of them either avoid or evade
the payment of taxes to the detriment of the country even though they run profitable
businesses that benefit from the country's costly infrastructure. I will address this in
greater detail later in this presentation. Madam Speaker, it is the government
that has been forced to intervene in the economy to ensure economic growth and guarantee
the improved standard of living that our people have enjoyed over the last 21 years of our
nation's independence. We did so in three particular ways: We invested in the productive sector
of the economy to provide jobs and create revenue. Thus, we built projects such as the
Royal Antiguan Hotel, Heritage Quay, and the Vendors Mall. We invested heavily in physical
infrastructure necessary for the development of business and the growth of the economy. We
upgraded the port at the deep-water harbour and the V C Bird International Airport, we
dredged the harbour and created the port at Heritage Quay, we built roads throughout the
country, and we took telecommunications, electricity and water across the island. We also invested in our people. Public
Sector data produced by the Eastern Caribbean Central Bank (ECCB) put Antigua and
Barbuda's situation into clearer perspective. The ECCB reports that as a percentage of
total population, the Public Service in Antigua and Barbuda is 15.7%, with St. Kitts and
Nevis ranked second at 9%. Other countries range from as low as 4.8% to 6.9%. As a
percentage of the labour force, the Public Service in Antigua and Barbuda ranks ahead of
all other territories at 28.8%, with St. Kitts and Nevis again ranked second at 15.2%.
Other countries range from 7.4% to 10.8%. Further, while, as a group, the Eastern
Caribbean Currency Union's expenditure on Personal Emoluments averages around 50% of
current revenue, the range in individual territories is from approximately 38.5% in the
case of Grenada to about 66% in the case of Antigua and Barbuda. Madam Speaker, while the private
sector laid-off people after each of the hurricanes we experienced from 1995 to 2000, the
government increased its employment. Had we not done so, the numbers of our unemployed
would have risen, and so too the numbers of our poor. With unemployment and poverty would
have come an increase in crime, school truancy and under performance in schools by
students whose families could not afford to feed them properly. We might well have seen an
increase in HIV/Aids since the purchase of condoms is hardly likely to be a priority of
the unemployed man's spending. After the atrocities of September
11th, the private sector again laid-off workers forcing government to defer a planned
reduction in the public service. In light of an increase in unemployment caused by
lay-offs in the private sector, it would have been an irresponsible government that added
to the numbers. Madam Speaker, it cannot be overstated
that the economic success that Antigua and Barbuda has enjoyed over the past 21 years of
independence is a direct result of the government's strategic interventions in the
country's economy. In the absence of a dynamic private sector, the government has had to
assume the role of leading entrepreneur and main employer. This policy has had its
detractors, but there is no doubt that individuals and businesses alike have benefited
from this policy, as Antigua and Barbuda continued to register positive growth in its GDP
year after year. However, this policy has come at a high cost, the most obvious being the
country's debt burden and its high public sector wage bill. This situation has occasioned the
criticism of the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank who are rightly concerned
that debt should be decreased and the fiscal difficulties resolved. But what was the
alternative? Had the government not intervened positively in the economy, would we have
had unbroken economic growth? Would our business community be able to function in a stable
environment? Would our people have enjoyed the standard of living that they do? We all
know the answer to these rhetorical questions, Madam Speaker. It is instructive that just last week
Mr Ian Bennett, the Executive Director for Canada and the Caribbean on the Board of the
IMF, told an Executive Board meeting in Washington the following: "The combined impact of lower revenues,
the increased demand on the social safety net and the need to make significant investments
to reconstruct the infrastructure as a result of the weather-related shocks has resulted
in a serious fiscal imbalance, and a large accumulation of debt. It is worth noting,
however, that despite the overall increase in the debt, the government did manage to bring
down arrears significantly from US$457 million in 1991 to US$120 million by 2000". Madam Speaker, that is a reduction in
arrears of US$337 million - pretty impressive by any standard. We have maintained a
reputation as a country that does not renege on its debt obligations. Need for the Business Community to
Contribute Madam Speaker, my government does not
enjoy the criticism of the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank. We would
welcome their approval of our country's performance and our policies. But, to get such
approval, the government needs either to drastically slash its expenditure or dramatically
increase its revenue. The reality is that while we can slash
expenditure, the main way in which to do this would be to send our public servants to join
the unemployed and to increase the pockets of poverty in our country. Such large-scale and
unscheduled retrenchment cannot be the way to go. While the government will retrench, we
want to do so in a phased and scheduled way that allows pubic servants either to go into
small businesses on their own or to find employment in the private sector. This is the
method by which we intend to address retrenchment. In this connection, Madam Speaker, the
government is promoting the establishment of call centres. Already 284 people have been
employed by one of them and another 248 will be employed by the end of this month. A
second call centre is expected to start in April. These call centres provide the
opportunity for the government to pursue an Alternative Employment Programme for
government employees. Therefore, government employees will be encouraged to take up
employment in the call centres, where the wage structure will be better. This will have
the effect of reducing the size and payroll of the government service while ensuring that
people are maintained in work. But, Madam Speaker, a more effective
way of dealing with the fiscal difficulties is to increase government's revenue. The money that our country needs is
already in the system. If the bulk of the business community would pay the taxes that are
legitimately due to the State, the government would solve its present fiscal difficulties
virtually overnight. For example, Madam Speaker, in fiscal
year 2001 there were 491 companies registered with the Inland Revenue Division. Of that
number 330, or in excess of two-thirds with an annual turn over of $695 Million, did not
pay any corporate tax whatever. This point is worthy of repetition: 330 companies with a
turnover of $695 Million did not pay one cent in taxes. Then, Madam Speaker, of the remaining
161 companies, 16 of them accounted for 80% of total taxes on companies of $42.9 million.
This too is worth repeating: Sixteen of 491 companies paid 80% of the corporate tax
collected. Just as startlingly, Madam Speaker, of
the 491 registered companies, 43 alone are responsible for arrears amounting to $93.1
million. Clearly, Madam Speaker, this cannot be
right. But what is even more wrong is that there are more than 4,000 businesses, other
than the 491 companies I have just identified, most of which also do not pay a cent in
taxes. Many of these businesses are sole traders, partnerships and professional
organisations such as lawyers' chambers and doctors' offices. It is obvious that the tax laws of
this country are being flouted - and being flouted with impunity. The result has been an
uneven distribution of the tax burden even though all benefit from the spending of tax
dollars. Madam Speaker, this state of affairs
cannot, indeed must not, be allowed to continue. The vast majority of the people of
this country - including our public servants - must not be asked to sacrifice, to be
laid-off, to endure suffering while some members of the business community simply refuse
to pay legitimately owed taxes or find creative accounting ways to avoid paying them. It is time, Madam Speaker, for those
delinquent members of the business community to pay what is due, or the government will
prosecute them. This is no idle threat, Madam Speaker. The patience of both the government
and the people of this nation have been sorely tried. We are now resolved to act. The
Commissioner of Inland Revenue will pursue tax avoiders and evaders, all the way to the
High Court if necessary. In this connection, I recall a tax case heard by the High Court
last year in which the Court found in favour of the government and ordered Texaco West
Indies Limited to pay Withholding taxes assessed on fees paid to an offshore affiliate
company. The government is confident, that as it seeks recourse through the Courts on such
matters, more often than not, it shall prevail. "Reunion 21" - Time to
reunite in Partnership Madam Speaker, our country will
celebrate its 21st Anniversary of Independence under the theme, "Reunion 21". An anniversary is usually a time to
renew past pledges and to make new resolutions for the future. As our nation reaches that
formal age of maturity we have reached the time when, as one people, we should renew our
pledge of unity; we should reunite behind the principles we vowed to uphold twenty-one
years ago. Among those pledges were to keep this nation strong and secure, never to let it
slide again into the clutches of those who would colonise us, always to provide for our
people, never to mortgage our sovereignty, and, forever, to be masters of our own destiny. Madam Speaker, Antigua and Barbuda
could be a profitable and prosperous entity for all its shareholders - the people who live
and work within it. It can provide healthy dividends for all. But first, each of us must
invest in her by paying our taxes and by pulling our weight. An Unhelpful Global Environment Madam Speaker, the importance of
investing in ourselves is underscored by the unhelpfulness of the global environment in
which we live. Prior to September 11th, the global
economic outlook was one of moderate expansion in the developed world. However, after
September 11th, the US slipped into recession and the depth and duration of the downturn
in the economy increased sharply. The Japanese economy, which was already in difficulty,
also suffered a significant setback because of its dependence on the expansion of the US
economy. Europe also experienced a decline in its exports as the US pulled itself inward
and bought less from its European allies. The result was a contraction of economic
activity in all the regions of the world, particularly those that consist of small and
vulnerable states such as ours. All of this led to disastrous effects
upon our economy that should be unquestioned. The main engine of economic activity -
tourism - contracted with damaging consequences for other sectors of the economy. The events of September 11, 2001
affected economic output significantly in the second half of 2001. Prior to the World
Trade Centre disaster, our economy was projected to grow by 2.32%. The Eastern Caribbean
Central Bank (ECCB) has since revised that growth projection to approximately 2.%. The second half of 2001 registered a
sharp decline of 9.38% in land based tourist arrivals compared to the same period last
year. For the entire year there was an overall decline of 6.62% compared to last year. With respect to Cruise Passenger
arrivals, latest data indicate that there was a sharp falloff of 18.49% in the second half
of 2001 and a total annual decline for the year of 4.19%. The volume of goods passing through
the Deepwater Harbour also registered a decline of 5.73% in the second half of 2001 and an
overall decline of 4.93% for the entire year. In this regard, 255,530 tonnes of goods
entered the Deepwater Harbour in 2001 compared to 268,773 tonnes in 2000. Other major sectors recorded only
moderate economic growth. The Transportation Sector was adversely affected by a fall-off
in the number of charter flights from Europe, as well as an overall decline in passenger
arrivals from the USA. This sector grew by 0.22%. The Banking and Insurance Sector is
estimated to have grown by 1.85% in 2001, a revision from 2% estimated prior to the events
of September 11th. Only construction continued to show
steady growth in 2001, expanding by 4%. This increase was attributable mainly to continued
work on the government and fisheries complexes and the building of private homes by
Antiguans and Barbudans. Despite the significant shortfalls I
just identified, no country or international financial institution came to our assistance.
They continued to apply their ordinary funding criteria even in the most extraordinary
circumstances. Hence, when the World Bank was
formulating a package of emergency assistance to alleviate the suffering of vulnerable
CARICOM economies, made even more vulnerable in the wake of September 11th, Antigua and
Barbuda was classified ineligible because of the relatively high wages and salaries paid
to our people, and because the multilateral financial institutions disapprove of the size
of our public service. These developments, Madam Speaker,
should make it clear and pellucid to us that unity as a people, and the resolve to be
self-reliant by each of us paying our way, are not only desirable but critical if we, as a
nation, are to realize our full developmental potential. Overcoming Obstacles Madam Speaker, we are indeed a small
country, but as Janil Williams showed us, size need not be an obstacle to scaling the
heights of greatness. Stamina, strength of character, proper planning and preparation, and
an unwillingness to concede victory catapulted Janil Williams to first place in the Junior
Pan American Games that took place in Argentina last year. What makes this achievement so
amazing, apart from Janil's tender age and slender frame, is the fact that while she did
not have the high-quality facilities and frequency of competition that athletes from
larger countries of the Americas enjoyed, she practiced and prepared using meagre
facilities - and triumphed. This indicates to us, Madam Speaker, that the will to win is
the most potent ingredient in any successful campaign, be it athletic or economic. In this
regard, Janil Williams has confirmed to us, as have Cultural Ambassadors Leston Jacobs
(Young Destroyer), Kareta Farrell (Lady Challenger) and Kimberley King (Little Kimmey),
that if we as a country clearly articulate our goals, devise the means through which we
can achieve these goals, and muster the courage and the discipline that are necessary to
stay the course, Antigua and Barbuda will negotiate successfully its current challenges. Addressing the Difficulties Madam Speaker, I now wish to focus on
the ways in which this Budget will address the difficulties that we currently face. At the outset, let me say that the
Budget is a realistic appraisal of our situation, including the need to maintain a
high-level of employment in the country in everyone's economic and social interest. A Programme of Adjustment Antigua and Barbuda has been in
adjustment mode since January 2001 when a number of expenditure control measures were
introduced, including a freeze on employment and a cap on salaries and wages. Negotiations
with the Antigua Trades and Labour Union ensued, culminating in the signing of a
Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) in June 2001. The MOU encapsulated a range of fiscal
stabilization and adjustment measures, chief amongst them being a wage and salary
reduction initiative in respect of Non-established workers and Ministers of Government. The Government is committed to these
adjustment measures and we will work closely with the ECCB and the CDB to implement them. Managing Debt Madam Speaker, I wish now to turn our
attention to Antigua and Barbuda's debt situation. Given the impact of debt on
Government's cash flow position and in light of prevailing market conditions, debt
management in Antigua and Barbuda is a matter of critical concern. The Government will
therefore seek to employ Best Practices in Debt Management with the major objectives being
to keep debt servicing costs as low and as manageable as possible. Improving Revenue Performance and
Administration Madam Speaker, Customs and Excise and
Inland Revenue account for more than of 90% of recurrent revenue. In fiscal year 2001, the Customs and
Excise Division registered a 9.8% increase in revenue collection over the year 2000 even
though there was an overall decline in certain yields such as Import Duties and
Embarkation Tax in the wake of September 11th. The overall improved revenue yields in
respect of both the Customs and Excise and the Inland Revenue Divisions were due in part
to the introduction in 2001 of a number of new or enhanced revenue measures. New Property
Tax legislation was enacted to assess property values more equitably and rationally along
with legislation to give effect to other measures such as the 2% Tax on Gross Income of
Unincorporated Businesses, Tax on Gross Income of Offshore Banks, Tax on net win of
Offshore Gaming Companies and Throughput Levy on Fuel Products. Also contributing to the
improved effort was an enhanced capacity within the Inland Revenue Division to audit the
returns of businesses and to detect instances of tax evasion and avoidance. This has also
strengthened the position of the Government with respect to the assessment and collection
of arrears. Tax Relief Madam Speaker, as I said earlier in
this presentation, cutting government expenditure is necessary and we shall do so in a
number of ways. One of them is by reducing the number and amount of tax concessions that
the government gives. While we will continue to give such concessions to the productive
sector particularly the tourism, agriculture and information technology areas, we will
drastically slash them for other areas. But cutting government expenses is not
enough. We must also take concrete steps to increase revenue by collecting taxes that are
not being paid. This gesture is designed to give some
measure of relief to the few companies that have borne faithfully the brunt of the
corporate tax burden. It is also meant to encourage payment by those that have
continuously evaded and avoided their tax obligations. The government shall also reduce the
rate of Withholding Tax from 40% to 25% and shall be looking at ways to simplify the rules
governing how depreciation is calculated for tax purposes, amongst others. Having extended the hand of
cooperation in this way, my government hopes that there will be an equal response from the
business community who must realise that the country needs everyone to play their part if
it is to continue to provide a good living for all. To help ensure a more equitable
distribution of the tax burden, the government will introduce a Minimum Alternate Tax
(MAT). This regime will be designed to draw into the tax net those businesses that pay no
taxes currently, mostly by virtue of their accounting methods. Under a MAT arrangement
companies would be required to pay the normally assessed corporate tax, or the 2% on gross
turnover, whichever is the higher. It is common knowledge, Madam Speaker,
that most of the companies in the Antigua and Barbuda are closely held and that a
substantial portion of their total income is ploughed back into the owners' and
shareholders' pockets in the form of directors' fees, interest on shareholders' loans and
rent, all of which are tax deductible expenses. Further, in the absence of any personal
income tax, huge amounts go out of the tax net every year in the form of salaries to
owners, directors, shareholders and employees who are relatives of the owners. These companies must now play their
full part, and we must bring to an end the situation in which 16 companies pay 80% of the
corporate taxes collected, while 330 companies with a total turnover of $695 Million pay
nothing at all. I am sure, Madam Speaker, that all the peoples' representatives in this
Honourable House will agree that this is not only fair, it is also just. Health and Education get Lion's
Share of Expenditure Under the Programme Budgeting system
that we have adopted, twenty-three ministries and non-ministerial departments shall be
responsible for the execution of thirty-eight programmes at a cost of $599,224,038.00. The
profile of expenditure for fiscal year 2002, is consistent with that of prior years, and
reflects the "people-centred" approach to governance adopted by successive
Labour Party administrations. I expect that in their contribution to
the Budget debate in this Honourable House, each Minister will explain his Ministry's
policies and work programme, and identify the benefits for the nation as a whole. I would simply like to comment on the
government programmes on which the lion's share of the expenditure will be devoted. The Ministries of Health and Social
Improvement and Education, Culture and Technology, together account for 23.49% or nearly
one quarter of total expenditure. The Ministry of Health gets the
largest single portion of the Budget with 11.83%, underscoring my government's
determination to provide medical attention for the old and the very young who are the two
groups most vulnerable to illnesses. It also emphasises the attention my government is
giving to curbing HIV/Aids in our society. We had our first recorded case of
HIV/Aids in 1985. Since then the number of infected persons has grown though at a somewhat
lower rate than the general pattern in the Caribbean. We take no comfort from a lower rate
however. Our objective is to control this dreaded disease and work feverishly toward its
complete elimination from within our borders. Education gets the second largest
portion of the budget with 11.66%. Again, this reflects my government's resolve to train
and educate the young people of our country to a standard that allows them to compete with
the best in the world in a variety of fields, including information technology. We intend
to boost the quality of our human resources and broaden our economic base. Education has
liberated our people from menial tasks and manual labour. My government will continue to
invest in education as a means of catapulting our children to the highest levels of
achievement in the business and professional world. Money will be spent on enhancing the
delivery of teaching services and improving the effectiveness of student learning. Although it is not reflected in this
Budget, I also wish to announce that the government will enter into an arrangement with
contractors to start the construction of two new schools this year to mark the 21st
Anniversary of our country's independence. The schools will be constructed on an
arrangement that will allow the government to operate the schools and to pay for their
construction over a period of time. Madam Speaker, the Ministry of Public
Works, which is largely responsible for the execution of Community Development projects,
and the activities of the Ministry of Labour, Cooperatives and Public Safety, along with
Education and Health, account for more than 43% of total recurrent expenditure. It is
worth noting, Madam Speaker, that in the case of the Ministry of Labour, Cooperative and
Public Safety, 60.39% of its allocation is devoted to fighting crime with the major
portion going to the Police for the provision of more equipment and training. In other words, Madam Speaker, more
than 43% of budgeted recurrent expenditure is allocated to Ministries whose functions
affect directly the welfare and well being of Antiguans and Barbudans. When recurrent expenditure is
disaggregated by programme, Madam Speaker, Health and Education attract 22% of recurrent
expenditure; and if Community Development is also considered, these three areas account
for just below 25% of recurrent expenditure. When other programmes that have a direct
bearing on the lives of citizens and residents, such as Security and Civil Rights,
Transportation and so on are taken into account, our people will benefit directly from 43%
of total allocations. Clearly, Madam Speaker, the government
has embraced the concept of development in its broadest terms. We are not concerned simply
with the rate of economic growth; we are deeply concerned about the progress of human
development. Hence, development in our twin-island state has been people-driven. It is no
accident therefore, that a significant portion of expenditure has been allocated to
programmes that are specifically formulated to maintain and improve the quality of our
lives. Long before the 64th Meeting of the
IMF/World Bank Development Committee in Ottawa last November, we as a Labour Party
government were aware that it was "
not sufficient to focus solely on
macroeconomic policy, nor only on the structural issues that are normally the domain of
finance ministers". The government is keenly aware however, that the fiscal formula
must be right. That is why, long before the Development Committee said it, we have been
combining market-based economic policies with the political and social imperatives that
are critical for ensuring poverty-reducing growth and an improved quality of life. Madam Speaker, I draw this Honourable
House's attention to the fact that the detailed estimates for each Ministry and Department
under every Head of Expenditure is appended to the text of the Statement as Appendix 1. Development Expenditure Madam Speaker the expenditure for
Capital Development 2002 is budgeted at $206,553,244 an estimated $30,000,000 increase
over last year's allocation. The global economic downturn last year which worsened in the
last quarter as a result of the events of September 11th, as well as domestic events,
combined to limit the implementation of the government's capital programme. Thus, portions
of this year's budget reflect a carry forward of development projects originally scheduled
to be undertaken in 2001. This year's Capital Development Estimate includes a significant
increase in the allocations to Reconstruction of Main Roads, Repairs and Maintenance of
Roads and Drains, Rehabilitation of Sporting Complexes, and Upgrade of the V.C. Bird
Airport. The main sources of funds for Capital
expenditure are the Kuwaiti Fund - $17.5 million; and the Sale of Crown Lands - $20
million. The Medical Benefits Scheme will also be funding significant capital expenditure
specifically relating to the completion of the Mount St. John's Medical Centre. Madam Speaker, the Mount St. John's
Medical Centre now stands seventy percent complete. When construction is finished this
year we will address the interior design, the equipment supply and installation,
landscaping and staffing. Within a few months forty percent of government's operations
will be housed in the new government office complex. However we will continue to renovate
a number of government buildings vacated by these ministries. The attendant costs are
provided for in the Development Estimate under the Activity Construction and
Reconstruction of Government Buildings. The buildings in question are those that housed
the Ministries of Justice and Legal Affairs, Tourism and Education. In fiscal year 2003 we
intend to relocate other Ministries and departments into these refurbished buildings, at
which time we would have housed sixty percent of Government operations in public buildings
and realised a 65% savings from our investment. Madam Speaker, Security has become the
world's number one concern since September 11th. In this ever shrinking global village
every nation has been called upon to strengthen its security regime. This particularly
concerns us as a Tourism driven economy. We cannot afford to have security breeches that
will in any way tarnish our reputation as a safe vacation destination. In response to this
situation, this Budget features a prominent increase in expenditure with respect to
security equipment at the ports of entry and improvements in the facilities and equipment
used by our Police and Military forces. Included in the capital estimates are provisions
for the construction of a new Police station in Barbuda and for repairs to the Warden's
quarters. In a few weeks we will host the
regional training exercises for the military and paramilitary called
"Tradewinds". As host there are certain facilities and equipment that we must
provide in order for the participants to fully benefit from the sessions. In this
connection, provisions have been made in this year's estimate. Madam Speaker, our investment also
includes logical improvements and capacity building in government operations. We are
equipping the public service to perform at its optimal level of efficiency. This year we
will continue our efforts to computerise government operations. By the middle of the year,
we will have computerised the Customs Division and equipped it with the ASYCUDA system.
During the course of the year Inland Revenue, Treasury and Finance Headquarters will be
operating using Oracle applications as the reengineering of government operations gains
momentum. In the next few months the Government Motor Pool will open with a mandate to
provide effective transportation for government ministries at reduced cost. Our aim is to
make government service the flagship of business activity in this country: efficient,
effective and fast. Recurrent Estimates Madam Speaker, I now wish to highlight
the salient features of this year's Recurrent Estimates. The government anticipates that in
fiscal year 2002, recurrent revenue amounting to $571,561,672.00 will be collected. This
is significantly above the $503,109,112.00 that was budgeted for last year. I wish to
emphasize however that this increase is not predicated upon the introduction of any new
tax measure other than the MAT, which does not add to the tax regime, it simply arrests
the incidence of non-compliance by many businesses. What will account for the increase in
recurrent revenue is government's decision to limit the number and amount of tax
concessions. In this regard, a committee has been established to evaluate more carefully
the merits of applications for tax concessions. This more rigorous system of assessment is
expected to yield an additional $50 million in revenue. This impact will be most evident
in that category classified as Indirect Tax Revenue, which accounts for 66.90% of
recurrent revenue in 2002. This category is comprised of Taxes on Trade and Transactions,
which is budgeted to yield $382,186,130.00 and of Licences and Service Fees. The other major categories that
account for the remainder of revenue are Direct Tax Revenue and Non Tax Revenue. Direct
Tax Revenue accounts for 16.10% of recurrent revenue and is comprised of Taxes on Income
and Taxes on Property, which are expected to yield $80,475,010.00 and $11,525,010.00
respectively. Worthy of note is the comparison between the amount approved for Taxes on
Income for fiscal year 2001, $62,200,010.00 and that being budgeted for 2002,
$80,475,010.00. There is a very simple explanation for this increase in anticipated
revenue, Madam Speaker: the Inland Revenue Department will no longer budget for shortfalls
resulting from tax evasion and avoidance. Non Tax Revenue accounts for 16.65% of
recurrent revenue and is derived from Income from Property and Rights, Licences and
Service Fees and Commercial Operations. The most significant increase between the amount
approved in 2001 and that budgeted for 2002 is evident in the sub-category Commercial
Operations, and in particular Sale of Crown Land, which has moved from $6,700,000.00 to
$17,600,000.00. This is to provide for the Initiative mentioned earlier in which
government would make parcels of land available to public servants. Financing the Deficit In light of the foregoing, the
question naturally arises as to how the recurrent deficit of $27,662,366.00 will be
financed. We intend to do so from the sale of
lands for five specific projects. These are: I will now explain each of these
projects in greater detail. In the case of the residential tourism project, one of the
lessons of September 11th is the need to diversify our tourism product. We cannot continue
to rely on the chance that visitors will continue to come to our shores in the numbers
required to sustain earnings to the economy. Therefore, we have to adopt a strategy
that has been employed successfully in The Bahamas, Barbados and Jamaica and which worked
well in Montserrat until the eruption of the Soufriere Hills volcano. That strategy is to
develop 'residential tourism'. Under this scheme, developers will be invited to develop
100 acres of land on which to build homes for people of high-worth from all over the
world. These will be people who want a tropical home of their own to use primarily in the
winter period, but also at various other times during the year. This project would not only bring in
immediate cash to the Treasury, it would also sustain the government's cash in-take year
after year since the taxes on these properties would be quite sizeable. The additional
benefits of the project would be the guaranteed presence of a number of high-worth persons
throughout the year. They would employ people to provide various services to their homes,
and they would add to the volume of goods purchased from the local business community. The second land project is the
continuation of the 'Land for Youth' scheme. My administration undertook to empower young
people in our country. We started this project in 1999 and it has continued successfully
since then. Today, more young people own land than at any other time in our nation's
history. Ownership has given them a sense of deep involvement in our country and has
heightened their interest in contributing to its continued prosperity. Thus, their
ownership of land is not only meritorious in itself; it has the additional benefit of
underscoring their patriotism. The third scheme is to provide land
for nationals to build their homes. Already both the Social Security Scheme and the
Central Housing and Planning Authority have done much to help nationals to own their own
homes. The various housing estates that have been built are impressive and speak to the
pride that our people have always taken in their homes, their gardens and their
communities. More lands will be made available to CHAPA for sale to nationals. The fourth scheme involves the Antigua
and Barbuda Diaspora - those Antiguans and Barbudans who left their native land in the
1950's and 1960's to work in the United Kingdom, the United States and Canada. Over the
years, many of these people never turned their backs on their native country even though
they adopted the citizenship of their second homes. They sent money home to look after
relatives and to help in times of dire circumstances. Many of them have now reached
retirement age, and they wish to spend their twilight years at home. The government
intends to sell 100 acres of land to returning nationals. Apart from recognising the
contribution that they made while they lived abroad, the sale of lands will again bring
money into the Treasury and provide a continuous cash flow from property taxes. In
addition, since these people will continue to receive their pensions from abroad, there
will be a steady flow of foreign exchange into the economy. The fifth and final scheme is
dedicated to Pubic Servants. Parcels of land will be made available to public servants,
including Nurses, Teachers, Police Officers and the wider Civil Service. This is not an
entirely new idea, but we are introducing a novel element, which is to waive the
requirement for any deposits up front. Instead, monthly deductions will be made from
salaries and wages, similar to deductions made for car loans, to pay for the land. This
situation would be a win-win situation for all concerned: public servants will be able to
acquire land, while the government will be able to reduce its outlay for salaries and
wages. We would all agree that this proposal is preferable to either retrenchment or an
absolute reduction in salaries and wages. While these five projects will take at
least five years to be realised completely, government expects that the sale of lands this
year will yield revenue to cover part of the deficit identified in this Budget. The
balance will have to be covered, Madam Speaker, in the same way that all CARICOM
governments are covering the shortfalls in their revenue this year - and that is by
borrowing. The shortfall in revenue to the whole
of CARICOM as a result of the global recession and the effects of September 11th is
estimated at US$200 million. Every country will have to borrow. In our case, Madam
Speaker, government will seek the best possible terms for any such borrowing in order to
continue to keep debt servicing as low as and as manageable as possible. A More Transparent Financial System Madam Speaker, in my last Budget
Statement, I had indicated that the 2001 Budget would "set us on the road to a modern
and transparent financial system and the restoration of fiscal balance
" We are
indeed on that road, and although there is some distance yet to travel, we remain
undeterred. With respect to the implementation of measures to ensure a more transparent
financial system, programme budgeting was introduced last year. The 2001 Antigua and
Barbuda Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure represented only the basic format and
structural aspects of the initiative. This year, the Budget Office will focus on the
Performance aspect of Programme Budgeting so as to measure the operations of ministries
and departments against pre-determined, objective performance criteria. With respect to transparency on a more
global level and specifically with respect the government's accounts, it will be recalled
that in the Throne Speech at the opening of this Parliament it was announced that audited
accounts for the five years, 1990 to 1994 inclusive, will be laid in Parliament today, and
the remaining years, including 2001, will be submitted no later than December this year. Madam Speaker, the government has
always contended that the delay in submitting these accounts was not an attempt to conceal
information from the Public Accounts Committee. My administration has been very keen to
make its operations completely transparent. For that reason, we secured the services of
two top Treasury Consultants from India to computerise the system and bring the accounts
up to date. Along with the staff of the Treasury, they have done so. I take this
opportunity to pay tribute to the hard work of the Director of Audit and staff who have
worked diligently to audit these accounts. Now that the backlog has been cleared
government accounts will be presented to this Honourable House in a timely manner, raising
even further the level of transparency of government operations. Conclusion Madam Speaker, I would like to thank
Senator Asot Michael and the team of devoted staff at both the senior and junior level in
the Ministry of Finance and its departments who have all worked hard both to keep the
government's finances viable and on the preparation of this Budget. In this budget the government has
found creative ways to meet the economic challenges of today, while keeping an eye on the
future. We tackle debt and deficit, new global developments and requirements since
September 11th, and the need for diversification in an increasingly competitive world
market. We also addressed the social issues -
the everyday needs of our citizens for homes and hospitals, for infrastructure and
protection from crime, for education and employment, and for community services and
community empowerment. Our country has made considerable
strides over the past twenty-one years. They are strides of which we have a right to be
proud. The 21st Year of our anniversary of
Independence is a time to consolidate our gains and invest in our future. This Budget sets
our nation on that path, and I commend it to this Honourable House. APPENDIX TO BUDGET STATEMENT HEADS OF EXPENDITURE E1 GOVERNOR GENERAL E2 LEGISLATURE E3 CABINET E4 JUDICIAL E5 SERVICE COMMISSIONS A. Public Service Commission $242,094 TOTAL EXPENDITURE $445,677 E6 AUDIT E7 PENSIONS AND GRATITUTIES HEAD E8 CHARGES ON ACCOUNT OF THE
PUBLIC DEBT Domestic Amortization: $64,053,093 In 2001 the government continued its
efforts to restructure its outstanding arrears and make current payments. EC$6.9m in
arrears with the Kuwait Fund for Economic Development (KFED) and EC$1.6m with The Peoples
Republic of China (PRC) were rescheduled. Additionally the government was able to secure
financing of ¥30m with PRC for major capital projects. Our projected disbursements in
2002 will be approximately EC$118m. Regional Government Securities
Market Current legislation limits the maximum
amount of treasury bills and bonds outstanding to a proportion of revenue. This limitation
has forced the government to secure alternative sources of financing at a higher cost.
Under the guidance of the Eastern Caribbean Central Bank which acts as Fiscal Agent for
member governments, the Regional Government Securities Market (RGSM) will facilitate
access to a wider source of funds and therefore provide greater scope and flexibility in
the planning process. This will ultimately help the governments in the union to achieve
significant cost savings. E10 PRIME MINISTER'S MINISTRY A. Prime Minister's Office $ 8,602,781 TOTAL EXPENDITURE $38,713,841 E15 MINISTRY OF FINANCE A. Ministry Headquarters $21,002,766 TOTAL EXPENDITURE $47,907,193 E20 MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE, LAND
AND FISHERIES A. Ministry Headquarters $2,548,968 E25 MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND SOCIAL
IMPROVEMENT A. Ministry Headquarters $ 5,446,498 TOTAL EXPENDITURE $70,864,799 E30 MINISTRY OF EDUCATION, CULTURE
AND TECHNOLOGY TOTAL EXPENDITURE $69,844,575 The Boys Training School has been
transferred to Ministry of Labour. It is now E75I. E35 MINISTRY OF PUBLIC UTILITIES,
HOUSING, TRANSPORTATION, AVIATION AND INTERNATIONAL TRANSPORTATION F. Ministry Headquarters $ 1,138,831 Total Expenditure $12,407,600 V. C. Bird International Airport E40 MINISTRY OF PUBLIC WORKS,
COMMUNICATIONS AND INSURANCE A. Ministry Headquarters $23,905,645 TOTAL EXPENDITURE $69,229,375 The increase from last year's figure
is due mainly to the transfer of Urban Development and Renewal from the Ministry of Home
Affairs. The Ministry Headquarters covers the rental of buildings for office
accommodation. Savings of approximately $4 million is expected to be realised when the New
Government Buildings become occupied. Works Division E45 MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, URBAN
DEVELOPMENT AND RENEWAL AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT A. Ministry Headquarters $1,535,565 TOTAL EXPENDITURE $ 4,049,782 The Substance Abuse Prevention
Division was transferred from the Ministry of Labour, while the division for Urban
Development and Renewal was transferred to the Ministry of Public Works, Communications,
Insurance and St John's Development. E50 MINISTRY OF JUSTICE AND LEGAL
AFFAIRS A. Ministry Headquarters $9,247,962 E60 OMBUDSMAN E75 MINISTRY OF LABOUR,
COOPERATIVES AND PUBLIC SAFETY A. Ministry Headquarters - Labour $
6,839,650 TOTAL EXPENDITURE $ 49,662,453 Cooperatives Department E80 Ministry of Tourism and
Environment A. Ministry Headquarters $4,344,165 TOTAL EXPENDITURE $13,100,748 E85 MINISTRY OF ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT, TRADE, INDUSTRY AND COMMERCE A. Ministry Headquarters - Trade and
Economic Development $1,704,328 TOTAL EXPENDITURE $4,118,442 E 90 MINISTRY of PLANNING
IMPLEMENTATION, PUBLIC SERVICE AFFAIRS A. Ministry Headquarters $2,605,435 TOTAL EXPENDITURE $8,947,042 In 2000/2001 the Department of
Statistics conducted a nation wide census, this was done to determine the overall
population of Antigua & Barbuda. Preliminary Census figures suggest a resident
population of 70,737. This enumerated figure consists of 33,643 Males and 37,094 Females.
The data collected indicates an overall population growth of 16.3 percent. E95 MINISTRY OF INFORMATION,
BROADCASTING, SPORTS AND CARNIVAL A. Ministry Headquarters $ 4,784,902 Total Expenditure $13,015,346 The amount budgeted for 2002 is
approximately $4.9 million higher than the figure budgeted in 2001,owing in part to the
inclusion of salaries, wages and travelling allowances of the employees from Sports
Division which were previously paid from the Sports Development Fund but with effect from
1st January 2002 are being paid from the Consolidated Fund. In addition the subsidy to
Carnival Development Committee has been increased from $100,000 to $1 million. The
Ministry has also begun restructuring and improving the curriculum and facilities of the
Non-Formal Youth Skills Training Project and has allocated an addition $700,000 towards
this programme for 2002. BUDGET STATEMENT "Consolidating our gains:
Investing in our future" Delivered by Honourable Lester B. Bird M.P. Friday, 22nd March 2002
| |||||||||
Send mail to Mickey Matthew mickey@actol.net with questions
or comments about this web site. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||